AI vs Officials

Side-by-side comparison of each call. Disagreements are highlighted in red.

SportShow all calls
Calls scanned
80
Disagreements
21
Disagreement rate
26%
  • WNBAWSH @ GS2026-07-21· 3rd Quarter 1:55
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Defensive 3-Second Violation
    vs WSH · Tim Greene
    On Stefanie Dolson

    An opposing player was cutting through the lane, which the defender was actively guarding.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    Although the defender was in the lane for an extended period, video replay shows she was actively guarding an opponent who was cutting through the lane within the three-second count. According to WNBA Rulebook 10, Section VII, this is a legal guarding position. The call was likely made because the official lost sight of the offensive player cutting behind the defender.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBANY @ DAL2026-07-21· 4 1:22
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Blocking Foul
    vs NY · Tim Greene
    On Courtney Vandersloot · drawn by Satou Sabally

    Drove to the basket and initiated contact with the defender.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    The defender was in a legal guarding position before the offensive player began her upward shooting motion. The contact was initiated by the offensive player who leaned into the defender. Therefore, the call should have been an offensive foul or a no-call. The replay shows the defender's feet were set and she was not moving into the offensive player.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBAWSH @ GS2026-07-21· Q4 5:30
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Defensive 3-Second Violation
    vs WSH · Cheryl Flores
    On Myisha Hines-Allen

    AI verdict
    incorrect80% conf.

    The replay shows the defensive player was actively guarding an opponent and exited and re-entered the lane multiple times, with the longest continuous time in the lane being just under 3 seconds. The call was made prematurely.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBALV @ TOR2026-07-21· 3rd 8:20
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Personal Foul
    vs TOR · Cheryl Flores
    On Julie Vanloo · drawn by Jackie Young

    Embellished light contact on a screen.

    AI verdict
    incorrect70% conf.

    The replay shows that the Tempo player (Vanloo) made minimal contact with the Aces player (Young), who appeared to embellish the contact. The contact was not significant enough to be called a foul.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBANY @ DAL2026-07-21· 4 5:15
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Offensive Foul
    vs DAL · AI Judge
    On Satou Sabally · drawn by Jonquel Jones

    Attempted to take a charge but was not set.

    AI verdict
    incorrect60% conf.

    The offensive player did create contact, but the defender was not in a legal guarding position at the time of the contact. The defender was moving laterally and did not give the offensive player enough space to change direction. The call should have been a blocking foul on the defense.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBALV @ TOR2026-07-21· 3Q 1:23
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Shooting Foul
    vs LV · Eric Brewton
    On Alysha Clark · drawn by Bridget Carleton

    Embellished contact on a jump shot.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    Although there was contact, the replay shows that the defender, Player E, was in a legal guarding position and the contact was initiated by the offensive player, Player F, who leaned into the defender. The contact was incidental and did not justify a shooting foul.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBANY @ DAL2026-07-21· 2 1:05
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Offensive Foul
    vs DAL · Maj Forsberg
    On Natasha Howard · drawn by Breanna Stewart

    Fought through a screen and embellished the contact.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    The replay shows that the offensive player used her forearm to create space against the defender, which is an illegal act. However, the call was made on the defender. Based on the evidence, the call should have been an offensive foul.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBALV @ TOR2026-07-21· 4 0:45
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Blocking Foul
    vs LV · Angelica Suffren
    On Kelsey Plum · drawn by Alyssa Thomas

    Drove into the lane and initiated contact with a legally positioned defender.

    AI verdict
    incorrect75% conf.

    The defender established legal guarding position before the offensive player began her upward shooting motion. The contact was initiated by the offensive player. The defender was in a legal guarding position and did not initiate the contact. Based on Rule 12, Section I, b(1), this should have been an offensive foul.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBANY @ DAL2026-07-21· 3 1:02
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Illegal Screen
    vs NY · Angelica Suffren
    On Sabrina Ionescu · drawn by Satou Sabally

    Attempted to fight over the screen and initiated contact.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    Replay review shows the screener was set and stationary for a sufficient period before contact was made. The defender, while attempting to fight over the screen, initiated the contact. Per Rule 12B, Section V-a, a screener must be stationary upon contact, which she was. The defender did not give the screener sufficient space.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBAWSH @ GS2026-07-21· 4 8:02
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Personal Foul
    vs GS · Cheryl Flores
    On Julie Vanloo · drawn by Julie Bies

    Embellished minor contact from the defender after a crossover dribble.

    AI verdict
    incorrect75% conf.

    Replay showed the defensive player made minimal contact with the ball-handler and the offensive player embellished the contact to draw the foul.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBALV @ TOR2026-07-21· Q2 1:12
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Offensive Foul
    vs TOR · Roy Gulbeyan
    On Bridget Carleton · drawn by Jackie Young

    Embellished contact from an arm extension.

    AI verdict
    incorrect70% conf.

    The offensive player's arm extension created minimal contact and did not displace the defender. The defender appeared to embellish the contact to draw the foul. Based on WNBA Rule 12B, Section VII, this should have been a no-call.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBANY @ DAL2026-07-21· 2nd Quarter 5:15
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Offensive Foul
    vs DAL · Isaac Barnett
    On Teaira McCowan · drawn by Sabrina Ionescu

    Ionescu fought through the screen and embellished the contact, falling to the ground.

    AI verdict
    incorrect90% conf.

    Replay shows that the offensive player's screen was legal. The defender initiated the contact and embellished the impact. The call should have been a no-call or a defensive foul.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBANY @ DAL2026-07-21· 4 0:25
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Defensive Foul (Blocking)
    vs NY · Tim Greene
    On Courtney Vandersloot · drawn by Skylar Diggins-Smith

    Drove hard into the lane and initiated contact with a stationary defender.

    AI verdict
    incorrect90% conf.

    Replay evidence shows the defender (Vandersloot) had established a legal guarding position in the lane before the offensive player (Diggins-Smith) initiated contact. Diggins-Smith initiated the contact by driving her shoulder into Vandersloot's stationary torso. The defender was not moving laterally or forward into the offensive player at the point of contact. The correct call should have been a charging foul on the offensive player.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBALV @ TOR2026-07-21· 2 8:12
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Offensive Foul
    vs TOR · Bennie Adams
    On Aliyah Boston · drawn by A'ja Wilson

    Wilson attempted to fight through the screen, initiating contact with Boston.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    The offensive player's screen was set legally. The defender initiated the contact by attempting to fight through the screen before it was fully set.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBALV @ TOR2026-07-21· 4 1:45
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Offensive Foul
    vs TOR · Roy Gulbeyan
    On Te'a Cooper · drawn by Chelsea Gray

    Embellished the contact by falling to the floor after marginal contact.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    Upon review, the contact initiated by the offensive player was marginal and appeared to be embellished by the defensive player who was not in a legal guarding position. The defender's feet were not set and she was moving into the offensive player's path at the point of contact. A 'no-call' would have been the more appropriate ruling.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBAWSH @ GS2026-07-21· 4 0:25
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Shooting Foul
    vs WSH · Sue Blane
    On Karlie Samuelson · drawn by Julie Vanloo

    Attempted a three-point shot while the defender contested.

    AI verdict
    incorrect95% conf.

    Replay evidence shows the contact made by the defender was on the ball and not on the shooter's arm or body. Per Rule 3, Section I, contact that is incidental to a normal basketball move, and which does not affect the opponent's freedom of movement, is not a foul.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBANY @ DAL2026-07-21· 3Q 8:45
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Offensive Foul
    vs NY · Tim Greene
    On Jonquel Jones · drawn by Teaira McCowan

    Embellished the contact by falling to the floor after minimal contact.

    AI verdict
    incorrect75% conf.

    Upon review, the offensive player used her forearm to create space, but the contact was minimal and did not displace the defender. The defender appeared to embellish the contact. Based on the WNBA rulebook's definition of a player control foul, this level of contact is not typically deemed a foul.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBANY @ DAL2026-07-21· 4 00:25
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Blocking Foul
    vs NY · Fatou Cissoko-Stephens
    On Sabrina Ionescu · drawn by Satou Sabally

    Drove hard to the basket for a layup.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    Replay evidence shows the defender, Sabrina Ionescu, had established a legal guarding position with both feet on the floor outside the restricted area before the offensive player, Satou Sabally, began her upward motion for the layup. The contact was initiated by the offensive player. The call should have been a charging foul on the offensive player.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBALV @ TOR2026-07-21· 3 1:05
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Illegal Screen
    vs LV · Tim Greene
    On Cayla George · drawn by Amanda Zahui B.

    Attempted to fight through a screen.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    Upon review, the Aces player set a legal screen. She was stationary upon contact and did not lean into the defender. The defender initiated the contact by trying to fight through the screen before it was fully set. The call should have been a no-call.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBAWSH @ GS2026-07-21· 2 8:12
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Offensive Foul
    vs GS · Angelica Suffren
    On Kate Martin · drawn by Shakira Austin

    Shakira Austin set her defensive position and absorbed the contact, then exaggerated the force of the push to draw the official's attention.

    AI verdict
    incorrect80% conf.

    The offensive player's arm extension was minimal and appeared to be a natural part of her driving motion to maintain balance rather than an illegal push-off to create space. The defender was already moving backward and embellished the contact. Based on the WNBA rulebook on offensive fouls, this level of contact is typically considered incidental.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro
  • WNBANY @ DAL2026-07-21· Q3 1:30
    DisagreementTimeline
    Official's call
    Defensive 3-Second Violation
    vs DAL · Isaac Barnett
    On Teaira McCowan · drawn by Sabrina Ionescu

    Cutting through the lane, drawing the defender's attention.

    AI verdict
    incorrect85% conf.

    Upon review, the defender, Teaira McCowan, was actively guarding an opponent (Sabrina Ionescu) who was cutting through the lane. The rule allows for a defender to be in the lane for more than three seconds if they are in the process of actively guarding an opponent. The call was an incorrect interpretation of the defender's action.

    google/gemini-2.5-pro